Who is in your Tribe?

by Andrew Lynn

How many people in the community (outside your board and staff) know your organization’s most urgent need right now? How many know the number of clients you served last month? How many people could articulate your organization’s mission and vision for change in the next decade?

How many people would you say are in your organization’s tribe*?

In 2008 75% of nonprofit income came from individuals (USA Giving Report). As corporate giving and foundations tighten their belts for the foreseeable future, it’s a critical time to think about how you’re engaging individuals in your mission.

Successful non-profits have found ways to build and lead their tribe of followers, groups from which they can draw donors, volunteers, and event attendees. The first step is overcoming outdated communication models that prevent your tribe from growing.

Most people are not a part of a nonprofit tribe, but they say they want to be. One survey shows 7 in 10 Americans say causes like health research, education, or the environment are personally important to them, but less than 2 in 10 donated their time to these causes last year (The Service Gap). That’s 152 million Americans (give or take a few million who just want to appear concerned) who report caring personally about a cause but failed to find an organization that will engage them. Some of that 152 million may give money to charity, but statistics would suggest their giving would be much greater if they had given their time to the organization as well.

Your tribe is out there waiting for a leader. Most people have a natural inclination to join a tribe and be part of something bigger than themselves. Look at the camaraderie that exists among Mac users, or the success the Obama campaign had in turning many $80 gifts (the average online contribution) into $500 million. Before Apple and Obama, these people were out there with the same passions and interests, but it took a leader to engage them. It's the same way with nonprofit tribes. There are people out there with passionate concern for education or poverty (just think how passionate people get about politics), but they've never found an organization that engages that passion.

Your tribe wants what you're offering. Many times nonprofits lose sight of the value of the product they're offering to people. Not only are people naturally inclined to join a tribe, they're also looking for ways that they can make the world a better place. Nonprofits (and churches) are the sole vendor of meaningful change in our society. Most people are waiting for a nonprofit to say, “Look at the change we want to make, now come join us!”

Your tribe needs you to enter the 21st century. Many nonprofits haven't adapted the means to engage their tribes the way presidential campaigns and businesses have. I see many organizations that operate their development/marketing/outreach efforts around the realities of twenty years ago. At that time communication strategies were controlled by cost: printing expenses combined with postage expenses forced nonprofits to think in terms of monthly, quarterly, or even a yearly communication cycles. Maybe thousands of people were informed of your latest client breakthrough, but they were only told once or twice a year. The communication cycles of the past ruled that only a handful of donors could be regularly informed of an organization's successes and challenges.

Tribes are not built on the communication cycles of twenty years ago.

If you've ever updated a facebook or twitter status, you know the world has changed. One guy I know asked his "tribe" on facebook for an air purifier to borrow, and thirty minutes later he had one at his door. The communication cost was zero, his message reached over 1000 people, and he certainly didn't pay to have a newsletter laid out, printed up, and mailed out to people.

Tribes are ready to be engaged in the daily work of your organization, but they need you to lead and engage them.

This is where many nonprofits make a horrendous error. It is easy to confuse the tools of tribe-building with the end goal. Signing up for facebook is a 5-minute task a volunteer can do for you; it won't get you a tribe. Tribe-building is an organization-wide vision that requires a holistic vision of how to engage a large group of people with steady information and opportunities to be part of your mission. It goes back to the first questions of this post: how many people actually feel engaged by your organization? Could you invite some of your print newsletter recipients or annual appeal recipients to engage with you more regularly? Could you focus your next event on laying out a 10-year vision and telling people how they can play a part in it?

Constare can help you develop a plan that builds a tribe of people around your organization. As other funding sources dwindle, it may be a good time to look at how you're engaging individuals. We'd be happy to provide you a free consultation session on building a vision of doubling, tripling, or maybe even building from scratch a group of people engaged with your organization's mission.

To learn more please contact us.

*Tribe marketing is the brainchild of marketing guru Seth Godin, who you can read more about here.

How to grow and sustain your mission in a down economy

Do you feel that you're not moving forward?

Are your donor dollars not there as they were before?

These are trying times, not only for society as a whole, but particularly within the nonprofit sector. As jobs are lost, salaries are frozen and retail sales are hitting a plateau, individuals and companies are looking to tighten their belts. The first hole to be ratcheted up, invariably, is discretionary funds for charity (Not the $5 lattes)! You're not alone, and in your role as a nonprofit administrator, board member, volunteer or even friend realize first hand that you have two choices: dig in and hold your line (which resembles the sand being swept away under your feet at the ocean), or you can grow your funding strategies (Yes, I said grow) during this period.

The first step everyone takes is looking to cut internal costs. That might mean using the backside of scrap paper or lowering the thermostat in the office, but those are just efficient business changes. These actions are not growing your income; these are just smart cost-cutting actions. An initial step should be looking at your present income streams and deciding which ones are not being fully vetted, or in other words, who or what is eating into those hard costs. For example, your special event goes to the same location year in and year out, but does the price of the plated meal go up? Maybe this year, it’s time to bid out your event to several competitors (seeing if that per plate price drops $2-3). It's really nothing extraordinary that needs to be done, but it's essential that you look at how you present yourselves to the larger community when asking for donations. Have you updated your outcomes and measurements to show donors how critical your mission is to society? Perhaps, now is the time to work on some new grant-proposals to provide for capital and/or one-time project start-up costs, thus relieving pressure on your main sources of income.

There is no good rule of thumb or industry standard as to how to best evaluate your income streams, but I'm of the opinion that no source should account for more than 1/5th of the entire budget. Doing so only sets your organization up to complacency, which is never good. Therefore, you need to charge your board (and their version of a fund-development committee) with the desire to understand the current revenue streams and see which areas can be increased through a more direct approach, or through negotiations with vendors to reduce hard costs. Really, what this article is getting at is that it just takes a strategic approach to growing and sustaining your mission in a down economy. Now, more than ever, do people need the resources of the nonprofit sector. Instead of hunkering down, take charge, assess the situation and look at the resources you have within the organization, as well as those that you can draw on from the larger nonprofit community to help you meet these financial goals.